I didn't want to post this on the MuggleNet boards, since I'd probably get torn to pieces by rabid fourteen-year-olds, but...
Come on, really?JKR is my favorite author, ever. But even I think she's being melodramatic, or at least the quotes are making her sound that way. What happened to "The Lexicon is great?" I really have no opinion on a printed Lexicon, since I don't know enough about copyright law to have a valid one, and there's no way I want to be all "RAH RAH, JKR!" A nearly completed year of college/university has made me cynical.
If her quotes were indeed not taken out of context, then I do believe I have lost more respect for her. Her mind is brilliant, but ever since this whole thing started, I don't know.
"If RDR's position is accepted, it will undoubtedly have a significant, negative impact on the freedoms enjoyed by genuine fans on the internet."How so? I can't really see it. Someone please explain this to me, because right now, it almost seems like she's going after one of her biggest fans. All I can see is this affecting profits for her own encyclopedia, which shouldn't be an issue due to the aforementioned rabid fourteen-year-olds who will certainly spend their parents' money on ten copies each if she asked them to.
"The idea of my readership parting with their or their parents' hard-earned cash for this is a travesty."I will spend my $7.50 an hour from being a general office bitch however I want. Honestly, I don't think I would have bought the Lexicon book anyway... it's already online. And I'm broke.
“Should my fans be flooded with a surfeit of substandard books — so called lexicons — I’m not sure I’d have the will or heart to continue,” said Rowling, who went on to characterize the H.P. Lexicon as “sloppy,” “lazy,” and “incorrect.”Or maybe it's writer's block. Harry was her brainchild; it's obviously going to be hard to let go.
Look, I don't want to be critical. But I needed to say it somewhere, and it might have come out much harsher than I intended, probably from all the "RAH RAH JKR" crap on the MuggleNet comments boards. I haven't really thought about HP in months, actually... the fandom, but not the books and stuff.
JKR, this approach is not garnering sympathy, at least not from me. You have the right to sue, of course, because you did create the series, and everyone has their own view of the law. Okay, I lied; I have an opinion, uneducated as it is. It's not right for them to try and make a profit off something already online anyway. But to get all "teary-eyed" is just too far. The Lexicon is composed of FANS, loyal ones -- until maybe now, not a rival corporation or something. I know what people say, that if they were really fans, they'd give up. But really, who would just step aside if the author they almost worshipped decided one day to completely reverse her stance on them?
This is probably a convoluted, confused rant. But whatever. I haven't posted in ages, so most people won't even see this.